Guest Post | In the News | Journal Article
Nicholas Pearce, Aberystwyth University; Richard Bevins, Aberystwyth University, and Rob Ixer, UCL
No one is certain why Stonehenge was built. This world-famous monument on Salisbury Plain in Wiltshire is thought to commemorate the dead, and is aligned with movements of the sun and moon.
It consists of an outer ring and inner horseshoe of large “sarsen” and “trilithon” stones, and an inner circle and horseshoe of smaller “bluestones”. It was built in several phases between 5,000 and 4,200 years ago.
The Altar Stone is one of the most enigmatic rocks at Stonehenge and is generally grouped with the bluestones. Despite its name (suggested as its use by the architect Inigo Jones in 1620), its function is unknown.
Lying flat at the heart of Stonehenge, the six-tonne, five-meter-long rectangular Altar Stone is a grey-green sandstone, far bigger and different in its composition from the other bluestones. So where did it come from?
In our new paper published in Nature, we have traced the Altar Stone’s source to north-east Scotland, meaning it traveled at least 430 miles (700km) to Salisbury Plain. This is an incredible distance for Neolithic times, before the wheel is thought to have arrived in Britain. This stunning discovery sheds new light on the capabilities and long-range connections of Britain’s Neolithic inhabitants.
Let’s review what we know, and how we pinned down the region where the Altar Stone originated. The big stones at Stonehenge (sarsens) come from a few tens of miles away, but moving these 30-tonne monsters was no mean feat in Neolithic times.
The smaller, exotic bluestones are a different story. Not local to Stonehenge, they typically weigh 1-3 tonnes and are up to 2.5 meters tall. The Altar Stone, also not local, is twice the size of the biggest other bluestone. It is not known when it arrived at Stonehenge, nor if it ever stood upright.
It was not until 1923 that geologist H.H. Thomas recognized that most of the igneous bluestones came from the Mynydd Preseli in Pembrokeshire, south-west Wales. Our ongoing work has refined the sources of these igneous bluestones to individual crags on the northern slopes of the Preseli hills.
Thomas also suggested that the Altar Stone was probably taken from old red sandstone rocks found to the south and east of the Mynydd Preseli, on the presumed bluestone transport route to Stonehenge. The suggestion stuck and, for 80 years, went unchallenged.
The search begins
In the early 2000s, we started to look again at supposed Altar Stone fragments in museum collections. Some fragments were clearly wrongly identified, so the time-consuming process of clarifying the situation began.
Initially, the Altar Stone’s origin was now suggested to be in western Wales, near Milford Haven. But at the end of the 2010s, we further subjected its fragments to a variety of geological analyses. These results hinted at eastern Wales or the Welsh borders as its source, and discounted the west Wales origin.
But without directly sampling the Altar Stone, how could we be sure that the museum fragments were genuine? Today, we are not allowed to knock lumps off Stonehenge, as happened in the past.
Novel technique
In the early 2020s, we started using handheld X-ray fluorescence analysis, a non-destructive chemical analytical method, on the Stonehenge bluestones – particularly on the many claimed Altar Stone fragments collected by older archaeological excavations. We then compared these with X-ray fluorescence analyses from the surface of the Altar Stone itself.
Sediment grains in the Altar Stone are cemented together by the mineral baryte, giving it an unusual chemical composition that’s high in the element barium. A few museum fragments were identical to the Altar Stone – proving that a labeled fragment removed from the Altar Stone in 1844 was genuine was crucial. These few, precious fragments could be used for our study, so we didn’t need to collect new samples directly from the Altar Stone.
Meanwhile, our scientific team now includes geologists from England, Wales, Scotland, Canada, and Italy. We had been analyzing a range of old red sandstone samples from across Wales and the Welsh borders to try to find a chemical and mineralogical match for the Altar Stone. Nothing looked similar. By autumn 2022, we concluded that the Altar Stone could not be from Wales, and that we needed to look further afield for its source.
At the same time, a chance contact from Tony Clarke, a PhD student at Curtin University in Perth, Western Australia, offered a possibility to go further. We invited the Curtin group to determine the ages of a series of minerals in two of the Altar Stone fragments, hoping this would provide information relating to its age and possible origin. This method dates mineral grains in the rock and gives an age “fingerprint”, tying the grains to a particular region.
Scottish origins
Our new study published in Nature shows that the Altar Stone’s age fingerprint identifies it as coming from the Orcadian Basin in north-east Scotland. The findings of this age dating are truly astonishing, overturning what had been thought for a century.
It’s thrilling to know that the culmination of our work over almost two decades has unlocked this mystery. We can say with confidence that this iconic rock is Scottish and not Welsh, and more specifically, that it came from the old red sandstones of north-east Scotland.
With its origin in the Orcadian Basin, the Altar Stone has traveled a remarkably long way – a straight-line distance of at least 430 miles. This is the longest known journey for any stone used in a Neolithic monument.
Our analyses cannot answer how the Altar Stone got to Stonehenge. Forests posed one of several physical barriers to overland transport. A journey by sea would have been equally daunting. Similarly, we cannot answer why it was transported there.
Whatever archaeologists may discover in the future, our results will have huge ramifications in helping us understand Neolithic communities, their connections with each other, and how they transported things over distance. Meanwhile, our search for an even more precise source of the Altar Stone continues.
Nicholas Pearce, Professor of Geochemistry, Aberystwyth University; Richard Bevins, Honorary Professor, Department of Geography and Earth Sciences, Aberystwyth University, and Rob Ixer, Honorary Senior Research Fellow, Institute of Archaeology, UCL
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
